Art Deco fireplace dilemma
We have bought an early 1900s house with lots of character and original features in need of full refurbishment. In the dining room there is an original light brown marble effect Art Deco fireplace which I do not particularly like but think it would be a shame to get rid of. I am looking for ideas onhow to design and decorate the room around it.
Comments (37)
emersideas
8 years agoThere was a question posted yesterday " 1930's fireplace keep or replace" there is some nice ideas on it!maria galvano
8 years agohi I love this fire place. play it up with deco revamp so different such a pity not to keep and love itminnie101
8 years agoHi. Do you have furniture or do you need to buy? Which way does the room face in terms of light? do you also have a picture of the whole room?
fujimusume
8 years agoThe received wisdom is that if something does not make you feel joy then do not keep it. I must admit, to my eyes, it's a bit of an ugly duckling. I had something similar in a rented house years ago -- I painted it flat matt black, which was an easier colour to live with than cream and brown tiles. Follow your heart.
Sven
8 years agoYou could re-tile the fireplace. If you cover the herring bone tiles with antique style delft tiles (or whatever you like) would really transform it.
ingabrereton
8 years agoJo Lamont
8 years agoI think it's beautiful! Please don't paint or re tile it. It would look fabulous with an ArtDeco dining suite & a mirror above. Keep your wall colour & window dressings simple & neutral.
kelvinrharvey
8 years agoIt can be removed intact, these fireplaces were constructed on a concrete form, usually in two parts, the base and the wall section. The base was cemented on the the original cement base once the hearth was removed, and the frontispiece held in place by cemented and or screwed tags, top and bottom each side, if this is the case they can be located using those small metal locators used for finding hidden pipes electrics. There may actually a possible buyer out there for this style, so don't just smash it off as a previous contributor suggested, at worst they make good garden decorations. Original to the house style fire places are available from any good salvage yard, checking out examples in similar houses may help, a walk early evening is a good way to get a random sample before the curtains are pulled over, otherwise just canvas the neighbours, for repro Stovax/Originalstyle based in Exeter would be a good place to start. Otherwise embrace it as part of you house history, but don't retile, never works and harks of Barry Bucknell 70's cover ups, and the best place for art deco interior restyles are for houses built in that period.
gilliifer
8 years agoto the person who painted a tiled hearth in a rental property; not acceptable. I like the fireplace and would style it up with cool deco colours and some dark wood furniture, metallic touches in gold or copper, mirrors and flowers
krissie13
8 years agoWe had a art deco style fireplace in a flat that we have just reburshied. If it had been half as nice as this one it would still be there. Its beautiful.
puffinrock
8 years agoIf you don't like it .... Remove it! It is a big dirty job and you do not want to do later on.Rachel Oakes
8 years agoPersonally, I love it. If you decorate the room around it, in an Art Deco style, as has been suggested it could be fabulous!
heatherkeevill
8 years agoIt's beautiful. Keep the room bright like decorate the room white and put some candles and nice green plants in the fireplace maybe in a beautiful copper pot. Don't rip it out. It's a beautiful feature. Even the mantelpiece is fantastic and you can stagger ornaments or candles along it. If you keep it and make it the centre piece everyone will comment on it.
Sven
8 years agoThe comments are a good mix of love - hate. Personally I hate it as it is too big and bulky looking, is in unfashionable brown and it will be difficult to decorate around it. It is also not original to a 1900's house, being a generation or so later.
If mine I would remove it and replace it with a smaller and more elegant piece that is not overbearing. That would make decorating the rest of the room much easier.
Sue Fendt
8 years agoHonestly, I would keep it unless you want to spend some more money repairing the damage it would cause taking it out with regards to the floor etc and putting something else in its place. Personally, I would keep the room white (the textured wallpaper upsets me more than the fireplace), fling a couple of deco/mid century pieces in and some lovely artwork. I think you will notice it less and less unless the room is particularly small and it is taking up a huge amount of space.
agee3
8 years agoWe had our 1920s house refurbished and had the same dilemma about keeping or chucking out and are glad about insisting on keeping the things we did... Your fireplace is pretty different, so that alone is a reason to keep it 'alive'. I agree with all the reasons for keeping it and keeping it as is! Going back to our situation, we kept things and have a mixture of old and new and think it really works. Good luck!
temple274
8 years agoDo you need it as a fireplace? If not why not just stud out that section of wall, board and skim it so it's totally hidden. You might need to go to the right or left as well to give balance. Instead of wasting all the boxed in space you could create display niches or bookshelves within it. You would need to box in the raised hearth as well, but get it right, add cushions and you have a sitting ledge or more display space. Don't forget you would need a spot of ventilation for the flue if it's currently in use and would need capping off.Pat Auld
8 years agoI am not offering advice as so many opinions already. Just goes to show its a very personal thing. Try and imagine it with all the suggestions and if you still think you will never grow to appreciate it take it out.ipend
8 years agoIt's ugly... If you don't like it, get rid, I like Art Deco styles, but that fireplace hasn't much going for it, and will be difficult to decorate around, you will end up compromising your other decor to make it work.
Hand Built Designs
8 years agoLeave it in situ- work on the rest of the decor so that it doesn't fight with it. I think it has a certain charm about it- pity about the brown tones.
Caren Bee
8 years agook, ours is a cream and brown colour, but when we first bought our house I also thought it was ugly! but we decided to keep it, and 3 years down the line we are glad that we kept it. all fireplaces today look the same, but you have an original and unique focal point.Emmanuelle
8 years agoNot a fan of Art Deco... And find your fireplace quite bulky and not very good looking. If you don't like it, get rid of it. You could replace it by an original Victorian one, from a local salvo, which would suit your house better. Don't decorate a whole room around something you hardly like!!! Be brave and keep us posted!gd11
8 years agoUnless you have got the furniture to go with it.....get rid of it! You could get a good price for it in the reclaimed building supplies or reclamation yard. It's best to start afresh with your own ideas, you might only regret it in the end, believe me then it's too late!
laura_hewitt26
Original Author8 years agoThanks ever so much for all of the comments and advice, there is some real food for thought.
our dining furniture is quite modern solid oak so doesn't really go with the theme, can't really justify spending a fortune on a whole new set of furniture to compliment a feature I don't love, particularly if it isn't even original as suggested!
I'll have a think about the options suggested and keep updated...
lucyrjb
8 years agoWe've got something similar and have kept it as it is original and tried to sort of decorate around it but it does dominate the room. I'm even more tempted to remove it having read all the helpful comments on this post. Thanks, LucySteve Challenger
8 years agoThe hearth looks like it could do with a bit of a clean. Push the servant call button to the right of the fireplace and put the maid to work.
Yasmin Chopin Interior Design
8 years agoHello @laura_hewitt26. You have the 'love it' and 'hate it' camp giving you lots of advice. When I work with clients I try to help them re-use, recycle or revamp rather than 'get rid' but it all comes down to two things: budget and personal taste. I'd be happy to help you come up with a solution that takes into account how much you want to invest in your property and how you want to live your life now, and in the future. If you would like to call me I will give you a quote for a 2 hour consultation - which may be all you need to get your project moving. My number is 07831 231 664. Best wishes Yasmin
Sue Fendt
8 years agoJoanna Biddolph
8 years agoThe problem is the stark cold white walls against the soft warm browns of the fireplace. I don't recommend going all beige but try colours from the same warm spectrum as the fireplace and I think you'll find it looks more natural in the space. Also, the round candles don't work with the squares and oblongs of the fireplace; find other accessories that enhance rather than scream at the shapes and colours and that could make a huge difference. So could a mirror or picture above it - it would shift the focus so the fireplace doesn't dominate. Work with it, not against, then judge it. These fireplaces are handsome; trying to pretty them doesn't work.
Jac Davidson
8 years agoYou could look at having a single piece of wood or tin cut to size to cover the basket weave tiles. This would cause minimal damage to the fireplace and give you a modern twist on the fireplace to work around
Mauro Perucchetti Ltd
8 years agoThis would make a great feature with the right surroundings. Have you thought of using natural venetian plaster to add colour and texture to this original fireplace?
Venetian plasters are easily applied and can add a luxurious feel to the room.
DESDEMONA POSTLETHWAITE
7 years agoI love your art deco fireplace, of its type I think it is best example I have seen. original period features are why we buy period houses. Sometimes fitting them into a contemporary interior can be hard but so worth it. May be some period light fitting would help.
apismalifica