Should I paint my custom, solid wood kitchen cabinets?

11 years ago

We have lived in our 100 year old home for four years. I am redoing my kitchen and would love a light airy look. My cabinets are custom made by the previous owner and I hate the color of the stain on the solid wood. I don't know what kind of wood was used but the color is awful. As you can tell in the picture, I have a lot of cabinets (27) and drawers (11) and the color of the wood is overpowering! Everything that I've done so far to lighten the look of my kitchen has not worked very effectively and I am stuck. Please let me know if I should take the plunge and paint the cabinets to achieve the look I want. Thanks

Featured Answer

Marilyn Wilkie

11 years ago

last modified: 11 years ago

No. Please so not paint these beautiful solid wood custome made cabinets. They are worth more than any run of the mill cabinets you will find...even ones that say they are high end. Please remove them carefull and sell them to someone who can appreciate them, or have them remove them. Then you can go buy the ones that everyone else ends up with. Many people appreciate what you have. Beautiful grain. It would cost a fortune to have someone do the same as that man did - IF they could get the wood. Just my opinion, as usual...

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (236)

frani916
10 years ago
My Kitchen cabinets were 'pecan' for years and my husband took all the doors off and sanded them in the shed. Then hand sanded the framed but not the inside, I painted them 'vanilla'2 coates and a 3rd with a small roller.
with brushed little knobs. Everyone says they are beautiful !. very happy with them but it was a lot of work but fun.
sherilt
10 years ago
No! New counter tops and flooring is all you need! It would look beautiful!
Related Discussions
HELP: Small L-shaped kitchen with refuse chute on wall!
Q
Comments (10)
Are you saying that cooking next to the chute would gross you out even if its covered? Andd to use it for its intended purpose? In the first picture, it looks like the stove is directly underneath the chute, but I can see in other pics that it is not. I think it is far enough away. If everything is bagged properly, it shouldn't be that bad. You will have to check on local code regarding having the stove next to the window. Code may make your decision for you. People usually just put shorter cabinets above that type of range hood. I would recommend doing so because you need all the storage you can get. The hood--being different from the bank of cabinets--will provide relief to the eye. With cabinets above, it'll still feel balanced. And, as for covering the chute, do you want to cover it and restrict access or do you still need to use it for its intended purpose and just want to camouflage it? To help the room feel pleasant, cheery, and light, I recommend using a glass tile. Even though it's applied to a wall, the translucency still shows and evokes a sense of the adjectives above. I think it would help keep things light. Consider a slightly higher toe-kick underneath the lower cabinets. It helps to create a lighter-footed feeling. You could also consider cabinets that have furniture style feet. for a more open feeling. Your kitchen seems like an ideal room to use modern, lacquered cabinets. I don't know if you like the super-modern look, but I think it could be nice. Maybe just for the uppers. Use a medium-to-light toned wood on the bottom. A limestone floor might be nice. Or you can do wood or laminate. You could go with dark or light. I think it's mostly about preference.
...See More
Ideas on updating/replacing the veneer trim under kitchen cabinets
Q
Comments (12)
I would seriously consider replacing the cabinets before putting a new granite countertop on them. The problem is that no one will remove the countertop at a later date if you want to change the cabinets, due to the possibility of breakage. The only choice you will have then is a reface. Adding new doors, drawer fronts, and veneered sides is just a facelift. You could also add new hardwood drawers with undermount cushion close slides, but by the time you do this if will be the same cost as new cabinets now. The cabinets you have now, frameless, particle board sides are notorious for having the hinge screws strip out the particle board they are attached to. Since you can't put a longer screw in them, because the material is only 3/4" of an inch thick you have a problem. You also can't put a wider screw in them because it won't fit through the pre-drilled holes in the hinges.
...See More
I'd love to have a white kitchen, but how to prevent it from yellowing
Q
Comments (1)
Have them use a high grade acrylic paint instead of a oil base oil base yellows
...See More
need help on kitchen island
Q
Comments (11)
Hi, I am currently renovating my kitchen. Pictures of my tiles are below. I love wood grain cabinets. However, i am at odds as to whether I should get wood grained or solid coloured laminates. My designer told me that I can only choose from Arova n Jennings brand. He does offer EDL as well. But I do not like the solid colours from any of these laminate companies. A solid black colour will leave finger print marks easily. And I think grey is going to make my kitchen look monochromatic which I feel might get boring overtime. Some advice is really needed.
...See More
bears72
10 years ago
Alehonea what happened- you said in February you were going to paint and get a professional to do it. Hundreds are waiting for progress pictures if you are still working on the entire project.
User
10 years ago
They'll look great painted. It's hard painting over wood stain- somewhere we got conditioned to preserve it. What's always worked for me is to go with what I want. Makes me happy and It works out to be the right decision every time. So paint and make yourself a beautiful kitchen! Would like to see some after pictures.
PRO
Nelson Rogers Design
10 years ago
If you are DIY kind of person the Rustoleum system does work well - and the glaze will help cover the grain. If you feel that the cabinets suit your needs - painting is much less expensive than refacing or replacing. If you are not a DIY kind of person - you can usually find a local company that specializes in doing exactly that. I have done this on numerous jobs with varying finishes - they hold up well and can completely transform the look. Look on the web for "cabinet refinishing". There are two excellent companies in my area - and I would imagine you can find one in yours. Good luck. PS I have never had a client happy with stripping and staining.
PRO
Faux Illusions LLC
10 years ago
fill that oak grain with Durhams putty and sand, prime with Zinsser Cover Stain, two coats paint, I've been using Benjamin Moore Advance, if glaze buy a decent glaze at least $50/gallon. Any glaze that costs less is not worth using. If glazing need to seal, use Satin Varathane water based
Allison Read
10 years ago
I just had wood cabinets painted because the wood was overpowering and not the light airy look the owner wanted. I contracted out with a pro because he had the equipment and expertise to make them look like they just came out of the showroom. It was a bit pricey but the finish is smooth as silk, factory hard, and much less expensive than replacing all the cabinets. Work is still in progress, but the difference already is spectacular.
PRO
Tile Circle
10 years ago
Yes, definitely! They could use come updating. Either painting them white or staining them would be great. It depends on what kind of look you are going for. As Allison said, white cabinets will brighten up the kitchen and make it look airy. Staining them a darker color would also look beautiful. It would go with your backsplash (if you plan on leaving that).
PRO
Creative Cabinets and Fine Finishes, LLC
10 years ago
Paint them definately. Looks like a combination of plywood and oak both not the greatest wood for cabinets - maple and cherry would be a different matter - the picture I am attaching is a kitchen we redid from oak to paint. Hire a professional - sealing the grain is not an easy task ...
hervery
10 years ago
hello there, I can not make this kitchen cabinets but BUTTER ones
kathytoo
10 years ago
Paint them! Don't listen to the people who act like you are committing a crime against nature or that that wood is no longer available. That is hogwash. I would take out a few upper cabinets too and that piece of scalloped moulding and replace the moulding before painting. It would open up the kitchen and make is so much prettier. The one thing I would keep is the way the drawers and cabinet door inset. So I wouldn't want to replace the doors and drawers unless they could keep the inset look which would be expensive. I love the look of inset doors. You can get rid of those hinges too and they will look even better. Unless you can move the fridge I would build the cabinet out so it comes to the edge of the fridge or just tear that cabinet out entirely. So just paint and please take down a few cabinets. Don't let anyone bully you with the sin of painting wood. Men are the worse about that but uneducated women can be too. Ask any decorator and they would say paint. They just aren't that great and even if they were they belong to you and you can paint them.
laurenk71
10 years ago
I had simliar cabinets. After 5 years of nagging my husband to let me paint them he finally caved. I painted them a creamy white and glazed the edges. They came out so good, we replaced the counters with beautiful granite. People think we did a complete renovation of our kitchen instead of a facelift...go for it!!!! Make sure you lightly sand and use a good primer before painting:)
sondramartina
10 years ago
This was posted a year ago. I hope they will give us an update.
mouzzer
10 years ago
You said it yourself:-) Take the plunge, paint the cabinets and achieve the look you want...via a professional who knows how to do it in order to get the best result.
PRO
User
10 years ago
Fine paints of Europe makes a filler for wood with open pores. I would suggest you hire a professional for your project.
Nancy Travisinteriors
10 years ago
There is no contrast in this room. Everything one color. That moulding at top should be changed out take a smile moulding to the ceiling. Remove those lights. Remove window covers. Can you add new counters top. A granite, go the grays and blacks. What kind of ceiling lighting do you have? Add recessed. Can't see appl but all should match. Paint, a soft gray. White pleated window shade from Lowes. Would update your look. Paint or stain cabinets. They are oak and very dated. A dark gray, make sure you buy cabinets paint or it will chip. Lowes carries.
Nancy Travisinteriors
10 years ago
Remove fan. If recessed light not in budget go stainless track lights Ikea has them. Easy to install from fan box. New flooring a dark gray slate or ceramic lay in random pattern. 14-16" tiles.
Nancy Travisinteriors
10 years ago
Use stainless knobs. No gold.
Nancy Travisinteriors
10 years ago
Backsplash a black or stainless .
Nancy Travisinteriors
10 years ago
Are those shutters on windows? If so leave but remove valance. Dated. Nothing over shutters.
sierrabb
10 years ago
If you want the light airy look then do it. You're the one that needs to love it. I did the same in my last house and never regretted it for a moment. Good luck!
PRO
Sound Painting Solutions, LLC
10 years ago
I would paint them as well. Two different colors would look great. Here's a project we did last summer: http://www.houzz.com/projects/327747/Sammamish-2013 . Also, I would recommend conversion varnish over painting them. You can get it made in any color, but it would hold up much better than paint. It is a hard finish. Best of luck :)
PRO
sstarr93
10 years ago
The lower cabinets-different color thing is a fad which I don't feel will last very long. The exception would be a kitchen with cabinetry which is varied in design itself, so that the color differences make sense. There are some European kitchens like this. However, stock cabinetry in a two-tone scheme is going to be obsolete soon, IMO.
Just my 2 cents and worth every penny. S*
PRO
Deborah Roides Interior Design
10 years ago
I would go for it. Painting willl truly transform the look of your kitchen. The grain is very busy and eliminating that with paint will give you a less busy and clean look. You could try a color on the bottom and white on top if you want something a little more interesting.
omagnes
10 years ago
It is your kitchen, so paint it or have it done, but forgive me for saying, get rid of al the stuff on the counter. Good luck.
Joanie Rogers
10 years ago
I'm just curious...after posting your question almost one year ago.....what did you decide to do?
Cheryl Irvine
10 years ago
I am curious too, did you paint ?
Ali Honea
Original Author
10 years ago
Sorry for not keeping any updates. I had unexpected hip surgery right after my post. It was may second hip surgery one in a year and oh boy! This time it really put me down! Had to learn to walk all over again, etc.. Anyways I'm almost 100% so I will be painting soon. I did use some great advice and took the curtains down, removed scalloped molding ( I knew something didn't look right ), clean the counters off (lol), new lighting and hardware. But I'm not posting pics until I'm done ;)
carole
10 years ago
hello alihonea,good to hear you are back on your feet! and when you are ready we will be here to see the changes made,but for now,look after yourself first...then the painting and decorating....
sarabeth2
10 years ago
So sorry to hear you had a little health set-back. Sounds like you are getting well enough now to renew your energies towards your cabinet painting project. I will be anxiously waiting to see the results. Don't forget us here on Houzz --- we want to see your beautiful new kitchen updates! Did you say you are having them professionally done or do them yourself?
juststaci
10 years ago
Paint them. I just chose BM "simply white" from a google, added quartz countertops, and wa-la great kitchen.
PRO
LB Interiors
10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago
Nice to hear you are recovering. Take your time, 'you' are more important!
Sheila Hanlon O'Shaughnessy
9 years ago
PAINT THEM and fast!
Sheila Hanlon O'Shaughnessy
9 years ago
i dpainted my honey oak with a grey and changed out hardware and I am very happy with finished product! Much cheaper than switching out.Good Luck!
PRO
Studio Dearborn
9 years ago
Painted oak cabinets will still show the woodgrain, unlike Birch or Maple, but it will still freshen up the look. You can also replace the hardware and the kitchen will have a totally fresh look. If you are doing this as a temporary fix, then don't be afraid to use something other than white! A pale grey might look really nice if you plan to keep the backsplash.
mycroftholmes
9 years ago
How are you feeling? I hope you're fine. And did you paint the cabinets??!! We need the update! :-)
add50317
9 years ago
Everyone says paint.....but I feel it is a sin to paint wood unless there is no other option. Yes the amount of wood is overpowering, yes you need to paint, but I think u might be happy just painting a little......? If it were me, ditch the scalloped edging, get something more modern. Paint the face of the cabinets 1 color and paint the trim of the doors another. Or if u want to start slow just paint the trim 1st n c how u like it. A very light color. Get new hardware silver would b my recommendation.

The grain is beautiful on the door panels, I would kill for those.....but the drawers r a bit drab so maybe so paint on them. I would hang sheets of colored paper up 1st n c if u like it before u paint.

Love the grain!
PRO
Alex & Lily Home
9 years ago
The grain is beautiful, but I would paint them white as well. Perhaps even a distressed white to see some of the grain. I also like the suggestion of white uppers and perhaps darker (espresso-like) lowers.
sheilaskb
9 years ago
Maybe you could sand and stain the cabinets a white oak that would lighten them several shades. You could leave the interiors the darker color for contrast and put glass inserts in some of the upper cabinets.
drdeb1234
9 years ago
2 year old post Houzzers....
chezparker
8 years ago
You are living in the house, so make it yours....ASAP. "What took Ya so long?"

I had custom maple cabinets that I loved in my old kitchen. When the house went up for sale, every prospective buyer said "Ugh" and they "HATED" the kitchen. We took down & donated a few cabinets (the long stack that closed off the kitchen) then, cleaned (TSP), primed and painted the rest of the cabinets a satin-finish cream color. Replacing a few upper wood doors with glass and new canned lighting transformed the entire kitchen, into a lovely place to gather. A grey granite counter-top installed with a coffee-colored tile back splash brought it from "Ugh" to "WOW"! Hard to believe it's the same floor plan. Now that we live with the beautiful updated colors, it is clear that the update could have been done years ago. When it goes on the market next year (we're downsizing), I'll miss it. Good luck!
helixg1
8 years ago
Have you painted yet? Would like to see pictures.
sierrabb
8 years ago
I have used General Finishes gel stains on wood projects. I used the Georgian Cherry on a coffee table, and Java for the wood trim in a bathroom. It's so user friendly. It goes on like paint, but has a translucent look that still lets some grain show through, depending how many coats you do. Look it up online, they have lots of how to videos.
Ingrid R
7 years ago
You said " I am redoing my kitchen and would love a light airy look" and that says it all. People telling you to stain them darker are not considering what you want. If you want them lighter than paint them. It's unfortunate that they have that scalloped trim. It seems like most old houses got their kitchen redone in the 90's. If those were 100 year old oak it would be a different story
ke815
7 years ago
Paint them!!! They will still be wood, just way prettier!!!!!! Benjamin Moore Advance paint works great on cabinets!
PRO
Ellsworth Design Build
7 years ago
Old post 2013
ci_lantro
5 years ago
Yes, it's an old post. However, one comment. I'm amazed a the number of so-called 'professionals' who thought those cabinets were oak.

They are not oak. The panels look like fir plywood. Frames and drawer fronts look like mixed woods. Some pine and maybe some oak & who knows what all else.
pstein15
3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago
We just custom ordered an entertainment cabinet from an Amish store. My wife wanted it painted gray, rather than stained. It is walnut wood. Painting adds 10 to 20% over the cost of stained. Not everybody prefers a wood look. We have a number of wood pieces and the shades never match. I think my wife got it right.
A D
3 years ago
@pstein15 You ordered a piece of furniture made of walnut and then had it painted?
pstein15
3 years ago
Well. My wife did. We already had two different types of Stickley wood furniture, and an oak dining set in the open adjoining room. That makes 3 shades. I think a change to painted gray made a nice contrast. Especially so with our gray carpet and gray leather. The natural wood look can be overwhelming.

Should I paint my custom, solid wood kitchen cabinets?

Comments (236)

Related Discussions

Ali HoneaOriginal Author

COMPANY

EXPLORE HOUZZ

CONNECT WITH US

Ali Honea
Original Author