POLL: Best Kitchen Countertops?

Emily H

8 years ago

In your opinion, what makes the best kitchen countertop?

VOTE and tell us about it in the comments!

Bedford, NH Farmhouse Kitchen · More Info

Granite

Marble

Butcher Block

Soapstone

Quartz

Corian

Concrete

Other - Tell us below!

Featured Answer

User

8 years ago

last modified: 8 years ago

We chose sea pearl quartzite and have had it for 2 years. So far, so good. Love the look. From a distance, it casts a gray color, but up close it has lots of green undertones. We only chose it for the island to make it stand out. Still in the process of renovating. Will be changing the flooring next.

Kitchen Renovation Before & After Pictures · More Info

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (123)

Elizabeth D'Orazio-Smith
8 years ago
Left my last house with granite and have concrete now. Love it!!!
PRO
Antony Architectural Stone
8 years ago
It depends from the project, style of the house and owners' lifestyle as well. We've used granite, marble and quartz in our projects. Granite and marble are organic and suit well people with health issues. Also, natural stone in general is much more stunning than other man made materials. Often issue with natural stone is maintenance but in reality it's like when you buy a silk dress, you just have to take care of it in a different way, the same with natural stone. Looking at old building and historic places natural stone does last forever. Quartz is too early to tell??
Related Discussions
HELP: Small L-shaped kitchen with refuse chute on wall!
Q
Comments (10)
Are you saying that cooking next to the chute would gross you out even if its covered? Andd to use it for its intended purpose? In the first picture, it looks like the stove is directly underneath the chute, but I can see in other pics that it is not. I think it is far enough away. If everything is bagged properly, it shouldn't be that bad. You will have to check on local code regarding having the stove next to the window. Code may make your decision for you. People usually just put shorter cabinets above that type of range hood. I would recommend doing so because you need all the storage you can get. The hood--being different from the bank of cabinets--will provide relief to the eye. With cabinets above, it'll still feel balanced. And, as for covering the chute, do you want to cover it and restrict access or do you still need to use it for its intended purpose and just want to camouflage it? To help the room feel pleasant, cheery, and light, I recommend using a glass tile. Even though it's applied to a wall, the translucency still shows and evokes a sense of the adjectives above. I think it would help keep things light. Consider a slightly higher toe-kick underneath the lower cabinets. It helps to create a lighter-footed feeling. You could also consider cabinets that have furniture style feet. for a more open feeling. Your kitchen seems like an ideal room to use modern, lacquered cabinets. I don't know if you like the super-modern look, but I think it could be nice. Maybe just for the uppers. Use a medium-to-light toned wood on the bottom. A limestone floor might be nice. Or you can do wood or laminate. You could go with dark or light. I think it's mostly about preference.
...See More
Ideas on updating/replacing the veneer trim under kitchen cabinets
Q
Comments (12)
I would seriously consider replacing the cabinets before putting a new granite countertop on them. The problem is that no one will remove the countertop at a later date if you want to change the cabinets, due to the possibility of breakage. The only choice you will have then is a reface. Adding new doors, drawer fronts, and veneered sides is just a facelift. You could also add new hardwood drawers with undermount cushion close slides, but by the time you do this if will be the same cost as new cabinets now. The cabinets you have now, frameless, particle board sides are notorious for having the hinge screws strip out the particle board they are attached to. Since you can't put a longer screw in them, because the material is only 3/4" of an inch thick you have a problem. You also can't put a wider screw in them because it won't fit through the pre-drilled holes in the hinges.
...See More
Awkward Blind Corner in Kitchen--Cabinet Solution?
Q
Comments (16)
Thanks, lefty47. This is an older home, and just as One Plan guessed it is a soil stack from the upstairs bathroom. You are probably right that the cost of a custom solution may outweigh the benefits. Another idea I had, along the lines of the worktop bin suggested by One Plan, is a recessed spatula and long-handled utensil holder. I found out that Lee Valley sells motorized tv lift kits like the one used in the video above. It would be a matter of getting the contractor to build the box to go on the lift. I'm still a bit hung up on the idea, though it probably falls into your cost-outweighs-benefit category! I may bring this photo around with me when interviewing prospective contractors, just to see how they answer!
...See More
Need help to determine where to place my inbuilt oven
Q
Comments (14)
Hi Fred, Thanks for the want of the precise measurements. The U shape area in my kitchen is 64" - 104 - 99" (left - centre - right). Height of the kitchen area is 107". The wall with the fridge has total length of 99" Fridge is 32" wide, 29" deep, 73" high (I bought this fridge on a good bargain but realized it was slightly oversized in this kitchen area, but got to live with it now) The wall beside the fridge is 23" deep I know some gap has to be left between this wall, the fridge and the wall mounted/countertop cabinets for ventilation I guess. So I'd say the cabinets on this wall will have a length of only 63"/64"? The microwave is 18.5 wide, 13" deep, 10.5" high The oven is 24" wide, 24" deep, 24" high. The wall next to the fridge which will have this feature cabinet 42" wide, 110" high which is next to the main door. I'm thinking the feature wall is kind of plain, but it covers up where the fridge is sticking out.
...See More
Sonia Burrows
8 years ago
Antony, what do mean by health issues? What is wrong with quartz in that respect? My husband and I both have health issues and I was planning on quartz in our new home, but now you've made me wonder. Please elaborate on why I should reconsider granite instead. Thanks
PRO
Antony Architectural Stone
8 years ago
Quartz is made of 10-15% (depending on the manufacturer and the quality of the material ) of resins. Phenolic resins emit formaldehyde in the environment. Since it's difficult to know what kind of resins are used, to be safe we usually advice our customers with health problems to go for a natural product.
Sonia Burrows
8 years ago
Thanks Antony. I wasn't aware of the formaldehyde emissions. Isn't granite an issue because of radon?
PRO
Antony Architectural Stone
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
That's a very good point Sonia! There has been so much research and extensive studies on granite radon content. We wrote about it on our blog http://www.antonyarchitecturalstone.com/blog/ since so many people were inquiring about it. If you are interested in reading the full studies, check the Marble Institute of America here http://www.marble-institute.com/default/assets/File/consumers/truthaboutgraniteradonradiation.pdf; and the Environmental Health and Engineering here http://www.eheinc.com/documents/EH&E.GraniteCountertops.UpdatedReport.pdf. Hope all these information can help you make the right choice for your home!
Sonia Burrows
8 years ago
Hmm, this is what Cambria has on their website.
Cambria is a durable, nonporous surface composed of 93% natural quartz.
Cambria surfaces do not off-gas and contain zero formaldehyde or
volatile organic compounds (VOCs).
How is it that they can claim no formaldehyde or off-gas?
PRO
Antony Architectural Stone
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
Are they talking about the resins that they use? You should look for that ...
kgoodson1
8 years ago
Love love my cambria. Installers said they could bring it in in larger sections and not worry about it cracking. Less maintenance in terms of chipping and absorbing stains. Downside is it is less heat resistant than granite (since granite is made out of volcanic rock and Quartz has plastic polymer resins). Quartz is also 20-30% more expensive.
Alicia Jeffcoat
8 years ago
Stainless steel
PRO
DaVill Blinds
8 years ago
Love Quartz
Dana
8 years ago
I voted "other" because Stonepeak was not one of the options. Mine looks like marble but you can't hurt it- even hot pots can go on it. (It comes in huge slabs they call planes.) I am tired of the natural stone options that look great... as long as you baby them.
Sonia Burrows
8 years ago
dana2060, isn't Stonepeak a ceramic tile?
Dana
8 years ago
Yes, Sonia, it is. But they make it look like real marble, or travertine, or lots of other stones. BUT, you can set hot pots on it. :-)
Lynne-in-PA
8 years ago
Dana, you have opened my eyes to something new! Thanks to you, I have learned that Stonepeak is available in my general area. It is now a (the?) top contender in next year's kitchen reno. It looks gorgeous online, and I can't wait to see it in person.
whocareswhoiam
8 years ago
Love the marble-ish look of quartzite but the contractor claims that it is hard for the fabricators to work with as it can "shatter" easily. Some homeowners on this site claim it stains too easy, others claim it is dull, chips easy, and many claim it needs excessive sealing vs granite yet others just love it and state no problems. I've seen homes that have beautiful Quartz countertops yet the manufacturer warranty does not cover buckling or cracking from heat...and in a kitchen it is always possible that a hot pot will touch the countertop if someone doesn't remember to put down "pads" first. Friends with granite claim that water must be cleaned up IMMEDIATELY but other than that they are happy with the granite. Laminate in our small condo was simple and easy to care for but when it was time to sell, the buyers wanted something more elegant. Bottom line, no right or wrong answer when selecting a kitchen countertop --- as they all have pros and cons.
PRO
Cast Glass Images Inc.
8 years ago
We're a little biased so we had to vote for Other (glass) :)
Leigh Jeffrey
8 years ago
Why not go commercial kitchen? Stainless steel- the most durable.
Suzann Lauer
8 years ago
Modest income, I am still loving my Formica for countertops and they have come a long way Baby! This was my decision on my kitchen renovation last year and this was taken with work in progress
jh77
8 years ago
I can't believe you don't have formica/laminate countertops on your list. They are practical, fun and inexpensive and can mimic about any other look. If I went with anything else it would probably be Corian because I like the feel/texture or one of the durable composites. I've never understood the love of granite. It is impractical and I agree with the person who says its wasteful.
Kay Dreher
8 years ago
We have countertops installed in the 1950s and still going strong. The aluminum-edged, red formica looks great! 60 years of faithful service: who can beat that?
PRO
Swain Customs
8 years ago
Butcher block countertops are our favorite, but maybe we're biased! www.swaincustoms.com
Donna Hurst
8 years ago
Those are gorgeous, Swain. I looked at your Etsy store and when I'm in the market for a new cutting board, I'll remember that mixed hardwood one. Beautiful.
PRO
Swain Customs
8 years ago
Thanks lyricfox! Much appreciated :)
Sylvia sylvester
8 years ago
Formica is the best, and one of these days it will come back. None of the problems of all the rock everyone is using today. Easy to clean, use, and inexpensive to have. . . doesn't break your dishes like rock will. I have three kitchens and I like my formica best,.
RegularClouds
8 years ago
beejays not only those things, but what if you choose to remodel? Want a complete different color or look? How easy to change comparatively speaking, and you won't break the bank. I know $ is not a factor for everyone but for us, the main reason for going with Formica was that if you go with Formica (or WilsonArt, etc.) you won't have to spend your life remodeling your home around that expensive countertop.
Sonia Burrows
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
Well Regularclouds and beejays, I guess that's why there's no such thing as "Best Kitchen Countertops". We are all different in our likes and dislikes. I had a beautiful cream coloured kitchen with granite 20 years ago and love, love, loved it. I'm planning my retirement home and am going to have my cream kitchen again. Yeah! I've lived with 3 different formica countertops these past 20 years and can't stand it. As the French say, "vive la différence"
RegularClouds
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
Sonia Burrows Agreed! - And isn't it interesting to see the "whys" that someone likes (or does not like) their certain thing....whether like you or opposite! (and, by the way cream granite sounds absolutely lovely! I'm going for a cream countertop this go-round too, Wilson Art, however....and it's actually the first time I've had the say-so in it!) ((and speaking of tastes, I perused your idea books, I love your taste and style!))
Sonia Burrows
8 years ago
Thanks RegularClouds. I had no idea that others could view my idea books. I looked at a couple of yours and like your style as well......but then again, we did save some of the same pictures :)
RegularClouds
8 years ago
Sonia Burrows I had to copy a few of yours this morning, hah! (we're building - my first house, designed by me, and physically being built by me and my partner, too! It's small, but built to perfection and WHAT A SAVINGS on labor!) So houzz is now my best internet friend!
Sonia Burrows
8 years ago
Well I admire your being able to build your own house. That's quite a feat. Best of luck with your project.
kimvignola
7 years ago
Hi - would love to see the results of this poll!
Judy Henry
7 years ago
I have quartz countertop and a butcher block island. I love how they come together and I'm not changing it anytime soon.
PRO
Hudson Home
7 years ago
"Best" really depends on the needs of the homeowner. Natural stone, quartzite materials, concrete, and others all have redeeming qualities for sure. My personal favorite is a classic honed carrara marble, which does stain...but I don't cook :)
magada
7 years ago
kimvignola - you need to vote to be able to see the results :)
Deb Byrne
7 years ago
I have had quartz now for about a year and really like it. So easy to clean, seems indestructible. I want something I don't have to baby, and this seems to do the trick.
Ann Whitfield
7 years ago
I have recycled glass. We love it. Looks great and is better then granite because you don't have to seal it and it's nonporse and won't pick up stains. You can given cut on it or put hot pans on it. Cost was the same as granite,
User
7 years ago
Nothing synthetic or semi-synthetic matches the beauty of marble. Marble is a decision of the heart, not mind. Advances have helped. You can pretty much prevent staining using a good sealer and maintaining upkeep. If etching really bothers you, many companies will "refinish" your slab to make it new.

Quartz is dotted and looks man made. Marble look a likes are either dulled, beige, or I can't get past that they look like little worms to me. Not very appetizing.

Quartzite it is becoming so popular it's hard to find a white one that isn't super grey. Often they are over filled with resin and have a yellow-green hue.

For grey and white - marble is the most beautiful.
User
7 years ago
Nothing synthetic or semi-synthetic matches the beauty of marble. Marble is a decision of the heart, not mind. Advances have helped. You can pretty much prevent staining using a good sealer and maintaining upkeep. If etching really bothers you, many companies will "refinish" your slab to make it new.

Quartz is dotted and looks man made. Marble look a likes are either dulled, beige, or I can't get past that they look like little worms to me. Not very appetizing.

Quartzite it is becoming so popular it's hard to find a white one that isn't super grey. Often they are over filled with resin and have a yellow-green hue.

For grey and white - marble is the most beautiful.
User
7 years ago
Princess Leia
6:54 AM
Nothing synthetic or semi-synthetic matches the beauty of marble. Marble is a decision of the heart, not mind. Advances have helped. You can pretty much prevent staining using a good sealer and maintaining upkeep. If etching really bothers you, many companies will "refinish" your slab to make it new.

Quartz is dotted and looks man made. Marble look a likes are either dulled, beige, or I can't get past that they look like little worms to me. Not very appetizing.

Quartzite it is becoming so popular it's hard to find a white one that isn't super grey. Often they are over filled with resin and have a yellow-green hue.

For grey and white - marble is the most beautiful.
Tammy
7 years ago
nnigrt, what is the brand and style name of your quartz countertop? I love it!
PRO
Havens | Luxury Metals
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
Triple Bowl Stainless Custom Sink · More Info

"Best" countertop is a personal preference! Stone, quartz, and granite countertops each have different qualities in regards to cleaning and maintaining, but in regards to aesthetics our vote is for whichever material compliments your Havens sink!
Judy Mishkin
7 years ago
sorry, i wish houzz would regularly post all of my activity instead of 'random'.

my countertops are LG rococo.
PRO
Kitchen Works-Leicht Los Angeles
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
Wood/Concrete Island · More Info

Vadara Quartz Surfaces is amazing. They have the most beautiful collection, all of our clients are ecstatic with the result! http://www.vadaraquartz.com

I attached a photo of our recent project in which we used vadara quartz!
PRO
Stacey DeWitt
7 years ago
Quartzite hands down. Beauty and durability of a natural stone. There is no comparison.
RegularClouds
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
Michigan Coastal Interiors, Kitchen Works-Leicht Los Angeles and others: It is beautiful, but there's always this in the back of my mind (

http://ths.gardenweb.com/discussions/2676880/true-quartzite-stone-and-radon) and while it may be true the radon/cancer risk is extremely small, I also know a family who recently (2 years ago) put in quartzite in their home, quite a bit, and their radon levels increased significantly. Even the most minuscule risk of lung cancer is enough for me to go to another countertop. The possibilities are virtually endless, WHY ON EARTH go with one that may be risky, even if the odds are in your favor?
PRO
Stacey DeWitt
7 years ago
Natural stone is tested much more than many residential products especially the many synthetics that are used both construction, furniture and accessories.

Here is a great article in regards to the topic posted by Environmental Health and Engineering. http://www.marble-institute.com/default/assets/File/consumers/countertops_radon_wp.pdf
RegularClouds
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
Michigan Coastal Interiors I would not dispute your pointing out that a piece of upholstered furniture has less testing than granite, however, with that said, you surely agree that we're assaulted with toxins from many different angles so why not reduce as much as possible? Opting to go granite free would be such an option! And, while your article is interesting, this article comes from the people who SELL AND PROMOTE and PROFIT from selling these products. Slanted? Quite possibly, I'd say very likely. (remember the tobacco industry fighting how cigarettes were not dangerous, even to doctors who would recommend Camels as safer, etc? Same scenario.) Additionally, radiation testing can be expensive. I doubt anything that is not required or mandatory will leave any manufacturers or dealers chomping at the bit to do much testing on their own, agreed? Now, I didn't say that granite was going to give you lung cancer and I didn't say it's highly likely, but there's NO QUESTION but what the risk IS THERE. It can give you cancer or other health problems. I say, again, why risk it when there are so many other options with lower risks? Because a sofa might be a worse gamble, or simply have less testing done than granite, that's not any reason to toss reason to the wind and say, "heck, there's worse" - I say the more there are potentially toxic materials in your home (as you pointed out there are!) the more you should remove or opt out when that option to go safer is an alternative. And, as I said above, my friend DEFINITELY got granite in her house that was high radon, no question. Bad break? Low odds? Who cares? It happened! That's scary! As for me, I went with a chemical free mattress and would definitely go for such if available in my living room furniture in something other than recycled plastic bottles presented itself to me, but simply because my options are limited with my sofa does NOT make me feel more secure purchasing potentially radioactive granite for my home. Again, WHY RISK it when there are so many other great alternatives? (* as an aside, a quote from cancer.org: ---> Cigarette smoking is by far the most common cause of lung cancer in the United States,
but radon is the second leading cause. Scientists estimate that about
20,000 lung cancer deaths per year are related to radon.)
bouncy5
7 years ago
I love my quartz, but I don't think there is one best. Another time and kitchen I might make another choice.
stingrae1625
7 years ago
I've had granite and laminates in the past and was never wild about any of it. I always loved the usability of my laminates but always had really ugly ones, and the granite I had stained and etched like mad, plus had spots in the polish where friction caused it to dull. We just redid our kitchen with honed Carrara marble. We have a marble topped dining room table and while the etching and scratched freaked us the hell out at first (6.5 years ago...), we had no idea that eventually it would all pretty much disappear into the table. We went ahead with the countertops knowing that we'd probably have that same "OH MY GODDDD NOOOO" break-in period and then they'd be "themselves". I've spilled a bunch of stuff on them already in just the week since the kitchen has been finished - chicken soup, oil splatters, pineapple juice, coffee - and so far, no stains or etches. The coffee splashes even sat overnight before I noticed them. The little scratches that we've noticed aren't bothering me like they might have, maybe because we're expecting them this time.

I just read in an above comment about how people with health issues should stick with natural stuff like marble. I'm one of those people. Highly allergic to formaldehyde and super bothered by VOCs. I had no idea that I was actually making the best choice health-wise! Bonus!

POLL: Best Kitchen Countertops?

Comments (123)

Related Discussions

COMPANY

EXPLORE HOUZZ

CONNECT WITH US